Thursday, April 4, 2019

How the design of Sedimentation Basin #2 may create a problem for Synagro's proposed crap factory on Grand Central Sanitary Landfill's site in Plainfield Township

The optimistically named* Slate Belt Heat Recovery Center or "SBHRC" that Synagro proposes to build in Plainfield Township is situated within 10 feet of a freshwater pond that is also being used as a sedimentation basin as part of Grand Central's landfill operation.  The sedimentation basin will have to be partially filled to make room for the Synagro facility, which is proposed to be built on a postage stamp-sized piece of land.

*Grand Central's advertising states the landfill is forecast to close in 2030.  After that, there will be no heat to recover from burning landfill gas - Synagro will burn 100% natural gas after closure of the landfill.

Proposed Synagro plant above basin (dashed blue line), landfill below

Sedimentation basins are designed to let sediment settle out, and the remaining clean(er) water flows away through an outlet and spillway.  In the case of Sedimentation Basin #2, there is no outlet because this is a former quarry and the water in the basin is exchanged through the walls with groundwater.  As a result, the water level in the basin rises and falls with the groundwater level in the earth surrounding the basin.

One of the regulations for sedimentation basins is that the bottom of the basin be above the level of neighboring wetlands, and perennial streams.  This rule was enacted after Sedimentation Basin #2 was approved.  Now it is proposed to modify the basin, and it is quite possible the new rule applies.  In DEP's deficiency letter, this is one of the deficiencies noted..

Let's look at a profile of Sedimentation Basin #2.  The diagram was submitted by Synagro, and is marked up to emphasize the location of Little Bushkill Creek, and the fact that the water level in the basin goes up and down as it exchanges water with the surrounding water table.  There is no other outlet.

It is obvious from the diagram that the bottom of the current sedimentation basin is about 75 feet below the creek headwaters, and the proposed basin bottom (black dashed line) after partially filling (which will require a permit now that a waiver is no longer guaranteed) is about 30 feet below the creek headwaters.

It will be interesting to see how this plays out.  On paper, it looks like a problem to a casual observer since the bottom of the basin is below the creek, and it should be above.

Of note in this diagram is the word "APPROX" used liberally.  Synagro has no idea exactly what the contour is of the existing basin, since they have refused to do a hydrogeological study.  There is no guarantee the existing bottom is at 620 feet - it could be far deeper since the quarry depth was several hundred feet at one time.  Under the surface of the water in the basin, no one really knows what is happening - including DEP.

Current and proposed bottom of sedimentation basin is below Little Bushkill Creek tributary elevation

Sec 7.1 of DEP Erosion and Sediment Control BMP's manual

Tuesday, April 2, 2019

PA DEP finds significant deficiencies in Grand Central Sanitary Landfill permit modification application for Plainfield Township Synagro crap factory SBHRC


On March 22, 2019 an environmental engineer in the waste management department of the PA Department of Environmental Protection issued a 9-page deficiencies letter in response to the application by Grand Central Sanitary Landfill to modify its permit to add Synagro's proposed shit bakery to operations permitted on site.  This engineer is in the same division as Roger Bellas, who issued an ill-conceived letter that was later retracted, in which Bellas indicated that carte blanche would be extended to Synagro to modify Sedimentation Basin #2 (formerly Doney Quarry #2, and now a pond) as it pleases.  Plainfield Township does not believe that the engineering that should have been done for the DEP to approve the existing Sedimentation Basin #2 back in 2008 was in fact done, and also does not believe that it was constructed as a sedimentation basin.  For example it has no outlet.  A sedimentation basin should allow sediment to be collected, and the liquid runs off.  That does not happen in the pond that exists.  An appeal of Bellas' letter resulted in its subsequent retraction.

Simply put, the DEP is not impressed with the enviromental aspects of the permit modification application, especially in regards to Sedimentation Basin #2.  For over a year, Synagro's engineer EarthRes has insisted that since the pond was approved to be a sedimentation basin, and because DEP issued a waiver in the past to fill part of it in (modify it), it should not be treated as a pond.  Bellas' letter indicated the water body would again be granted a waiver, and Synagro and Waste Management have assumed they would waltz (pun intended) through the pearly gates and grasp the elusive Golden Turd (see sidebar for how this project is likely worth millions a year to each).


The holy grail for Waste Managment and Syangro - the Golden Turd
(While Green Knights and the community reaps diarrhea in the form of a maximum $100k a year)

Not so fast - in its deficiency letter DEP is saying "OK, it is a sedimentation basin - show us you meet the requirements for a sedimentatuion basin and oh, by the way the requirements for them are more stringent now."  DEP appears to be coming around to the township's position, and this has resulted in some interesting deficiencies.

The letter is below.  Here are some highlights of the deficiencies noted:
  • The maximum tributary area for a sediment trap is 5 acres, but the proposal is for 24 acres.
  • The discharge capacity of the sedimentation basin is not provided.  The principal spillway must convey the discharge from a 10-year storm. (note the current basin has no discharge)
  • No dewatering device is proposed for the basin, but it is required to state the 4 to 7 day dewatering times.
  • The length and width of the bottom of Sedimentation Basin #2 are stated as "unknown" in the application (lol).
  • Show how the bottom of Sedimentation Basin is above the high water table, surrounding wetlands, and perennial streams (lol - the bottom is probably 90' below these). (!)
  • Sedimentation Basin #2 should have an outlet.
  • Sedimentation Basin #2 can not both pre-treat runoff and have runoff.
  • Flow length could not be calulated since there is no outlet structure.
  • Length and width of principal spillway are not specified.
  • There is no Post Construction Stormwater Management (PCSM) plan provided.
  • Neither the Little Bushkill or Waltz Creek are mentioned as surface waters that may receive runoff for the proposed project in the stormwater management plan or stormwater narrative. (!)
  • The application does not mention or contain calculations that address increases in water volume and impacts on water quality of the project. (!)
  • It appears the sedimentation basin is actually a detention pond, and if so it should take more than 24 hours but less than 72 hours to drain. (DEP appears to be asking "what exactly is Sedimentation Basin #2"?!)
  • The peak stormwater runoff rates shown only cover tributaries to Sedimentation Basin #2 - all drainage from disturbed areas must be shown, including those that bypass the basin.
  • Flow rates for the emergency spillway are not shown.
  • Insufficient freeboard is provided from the 100-year storm to the invert of the emergency spillway.
  • The DEP is not aware of any data that would allow an evaluation of the connection between the sedimentation basin and the Little Bushkill and Waltz creeks, and how the proposed modification of the basin might impact these water bodies. (!)
Synagro has 60 business days from the date of the letter (June 17) to respond and address each of the deficiencies noted in the letter.  There are some very serious deficiencies in this list - Synagro may very soon rue the day that it chose to attempt to take advantage of the DEP having approved the quarry pond as a sedimentation basin some 10 years ago, since sedimentation basins have requirements and current standards are that the basin bottom be about 90' higher than it is.  At the February 21, 2019 planning commission review, Waste Management representative Scott Perin made a big production at the podium about how Sedimentation Basin #2 was approved in 2008, and any appeal period for that approval has expired.  What he didn't appreciate is that approval is not what matters - a modification is now proposed and current standards apply as well as the design and construction criteria that DEP did not address in granting approval in 2008.  Mr. Bellas does not get to wave his magic shit wand and make everything ok to move forwards.

Whoa daddy - 90', up!  Get the big crane out, and let's get started lifting this quarry out of the ground.

Note that this letter pertains to only one of four permit applications.  The others are NPDES, air quality and the facility permit for the Synagro bakery.   This is the first application that is known to have received a technical deficiencies letter.

Thursday, March 21, 2019

Hazard Mitigation presentation Thursday March 21st (tonight) 7-8:30pm Washington Twp NorCo

Citizens concerned about municipal and regional policies relating to health hazards (eg biosolids, hazardous fill, etc ), may wish to attend this workshop tonight in Washington Township, Northampton County on Rt 191 at the municipal building.

This is a cooperative program between the Lehigh Valley Planning Commission and the Northampton County Emergency Management Agency, sponsored by the Nurture Nature Center.

This is short notice, but if you can attend you can participate in a conversation about hazards that may be in your community that can affect you.


Tuesday, March 12, 2019

Another class action lawsuit filed against Waste Management over odors from Grand Central Sanitary Landfill - proposed site of Synagro crap bakery in Plainfield Township

On Friday, a second class action lawsuit was filed in Northampton County Court of Common Pleas, against Waste Management for odors emanating from Grand Central Sanitary Landfill.  The lawsuit states that there are believed to be roughly 90 members who may initially be qualified to be members of the class.  There are only three named representatives of the class in the complaint, but rest assured the other 87+/- have signed on to participate.  Complaints of odors from the landfill up to a few months ago that have been received by DEP are here.  In the text of the lawsuit filing it indicates that the remainder of the class members are identified in recorded complaints.

We're pissed off and we aren't going to take it anymore



The first lawsuit filed is Huratiak v. Waste Management of Pennsylvania, Inc., docket entry C-48-CV-2019-00948.

If you are a resident who is being affected by the stench of the landfill on a regular basis, you should contact the Plaintiffs' attorney's office to see if you can become a member of the class.  This lawsuit was filed by John Kotsatos, in Easton.

The Court will have to certify the class, and the Defendant may make motions including challenging that certification, that the two cases should be merged for judicial efficiency, that the case should be dismissed, etc.  Stay tuned... how this plays out will depend on how Waste Management responds and how the Court rules on various motions.

Wednesday, March 6, 2019

Complaints against Grand Central Sanitary Landfill piled up over the years at proposed site of Synagro biosolids plant - subject of class action lawsuit

As reported in the Allentown Morning Call, and recognized here, a class action lawsuit was filed in February by affected citizens against Grand Central Sanitary Landfill, for odors ruining the quality of life of citizens living in the area of the landfill.

DEP spokesperson Cathleen Connolly passes the issue off as a seasonal issue in the article, but the fact is odors are not to emanate past the property boundaries of the landfill.  What comfort does it give the people attempting to enjoy the use of their properties if they are being made miserable while there, to say "it's just seasonal - hey, it happens with landfills"?  And how could they dream of selling their property if they wanted to move?


Over the past four to five years, a large stack of complaints has piled up.  The files below consist of inspections and complaints received in this time period.  Read em and weep - that intolerable stench is the landfill.










Tuesday, March 5, 2019

Lawsuit against Grand Central Sanitary Landfill over odors at site of proposed Synagro crap factory complicates picture


As reported in the Morning Call, a class action lawsuit has been filed in Northampton County Court over the increase in odors this past year at the Grand Central Sanitary Landfill, owned by Waste Management.

The fact it is in the past year is critical, since the landfill has been producing odors that travel offsite for years.  That is what landfills do, and why the towns in the area are done putting up with people's shit.  Both figuratively and literally are dumped here daily in quantities over 100 tons each - which explains why nobody except Nolin Perin, Waste Management, Green Knights and Synagro thinks a proposed biosolids plant processing 400 tons of shit a day is a fantastic idea.  It is the change in level of odors that has harmed the plaintiffs - they can't sue for whatever odors have occurred beyond a statutory period, such one year.

"We can't breathe back here!"

How this could affect proposed Synagro shit bakery

Even though plaintiff Robert Huratiak is quoted in the article stating this is not about Synagro's application, it can be.  The article also states that DEP has taken note of the number of complaints registered by objectors at the November 7, 2018 hearing DEP held on the Synagro application:
"DEP officials told Waste Management in the Dec. 4 letter that the landfill odors and “potential future odors” related to the plant were a “consistent theme” among people who testified during a public hearing DEP conducted Nov. 7 regarding the proposed plant."
March 5, 2019 Morning Call web article 

In the event this crappy proposal is issued permits by DEP, citizens and towns and the Delaware Riverkeeper Network will be shoving themselves into line to appeal their issuance to the PA Environmental Hearing Board.  One ground for appeal could be that DEP is permitting an additional shit stank operation on a property that is already generating more than its share of shit stank, and ruining people's lives in the process.

First of multiple lawsuits?

The pooper scooper here at the Poop and Water Extraction blog has snagged some solids in its net - and in the process "caught wind" of some intelligence information.  There may be more lawsuits launched in the near future, like projectile diarrhea.

Anthony Salamone's informative article on the class action lawsuit is here:

Thursday, February 28, 2019

How the fight over freshwater pond next to proposed Synagro facility in Plainfield Township may play out

As reported here, PA DEP (Don't Expect Protection) solid waste slinger Roger Bellas on February 14 retracted a letter he sent on August 10, 2018, in which he had stated that Synagro would be eligible for an extension of a waiver of a permit for encroachment and modification of water bodies that was originally granted Waste Management at the same site some 10 years ago.  At that time, DEP began considering the water body in question, former Doney Quarry #2, as a sedimentation basin - now known as sedimentation basin #2.

Plainfield Township appealed the determination in Bellas' August 10 letter, with a multi-pronged argument.  One is that there is no evidence that the engineering required for DEP to make the original decision was done.  Another is that whatever design was done, the construction was not as proposed.  For example, township consultant Jason Smith reported at the February 21, 2019 planning commission review that an outlet structure that was in the design was not installed.  Sedimentation basins are supposed to have outlets.  They are also supposed to trap sediment, which is periodically removed.  The township has suggested that evidence this is being done is lacking.  Note that the township was not appealing the original waiver.

Grand Central rep makes statement that appeal period has passed - so?

Waste Management/Grand Central representative Scott Perin made a statement at the February 21 meeting that whatever happened in 2007 or 2008, the appeal period has passed.  The township received notice, didn't appeal.  Tough cookies.

No shit.  That isn't the point.  Perin was also not on point at the very first review of Synagro's proposal in November 2016, "but we have over 300 acres" - which also wasn't on point.  They are now trying to cram this pile of crap into a postage stamp-sized property with less than 2 acres of open space.  Stay focused.

Apparently Perin believes the fact that DEP looked the other way 10 years ago means they can again.  It's just a hole in the ground - we fill in holes all the time.  Not holes that are ponds being used (allegedly) as sedimentation basins.  And no, not again, not with everyone in the community and the Delaware Riverkeeper Network ready to sue DEP's ass if they issue a permit.  DEP better move carefully, even though they are promoting this kind of facility and everyone knows they want to grant Synago permits.

New DEP regulations for sedimentation basins

A lot has changed on the regulatory front since 10 years ago.  For example - the first one and last one - since 2012 the bottom of sedimentation basins must be above the level of groundwater.   The surface of sedimentation basin #2 is at the level of groundwater - its height goes up and down with the level of the groundwater surrounding the basin (pond), since there is no outlet.

Synagro stated that when the proposed fill (100,000 cu yds) has been placed into the pond, the new depth of the pond will be about 90'.  A question that the township may be asking is, how can the bottom of a 90' deep sedimentation basin #2 be above the surface level of the water that is in it?  This assumes that such a significant modification would cause DEP to apply the latest criteria prior to granting the same waiver - a waiver that is issued for sedimentation basins that are properly engineered.  Point being, if you did or didn't properly engineer it 10 years ago may make no difference.  You need to engineer it today before you make substantial changes.

And whether or not it is actually functioning as a sedimentation basin is important.   If it isn't, then perhaps extending a waiver that never should have been granted in the first place won't even be possible.

Thus, there is quite a battle shaping up over the freshwater pond on the proposed Synagro site.  If Synagro can't fill it in because it can't obtain a waiver, its trucks will be driving in the pond, and employee parking will be below ground and water level.  They would need zoning variances for that for sure.

Let's not forget that even if Synagro receives DEP approval to partially fill the pond, the township is still arguing that its 50' open space buffer from a water body applies from its existing edge - this buffer would extend almost all the way to the north side of the proposed building!

Blue line through shaded area just below building is the existing edge of the pond

Synagro may do a hydrogeological study

At the February 21 review meeting, township consultants again stated they felt an analysis of the existing conditions in the pond should be required, and planner Bob Simpson asked Synagro attorney Witmer "are you going to do a study or not, yes or no?", to which Witmer essentially replied "no".  Near the end of the meeting, Hecht asked meekly, "what would you like to see in a hydrogeological study?" which appeared to surprise both planners and consultants.  Not because he was indicating finally Synagro might do a study, but because this is a question for Synagro's engineers.

A few meetings ago, Synagro's engineer Pullar stated "we're looking at that", the last time the question was asked "are you going to do a study?"  The typical answer for a year and a half was "no".  Hecht should have had the "what would we test for?" discussion with Pullar over a year ago.  Pullar seemed surprised last fall though when planner Dingle asked about water quantity, and Pullar replied "so you care about both water quality and quantity in the pond?"  Perhaps Pullar isn't the expert to be asking...