Friday, March 11, 2016

Over a century ago, the site Nestle is planning to use was developed by millionaires, resulting in property condemnation, bankruptcy and some positive outcomes

In 1898, a group of millionaires including J.P. Morgan got the bright idea to develop the Chestnut Ridge.  They formed Chestnut Ridge Development Corporation, and their plans included constructing a brick factory on the site that Nestle plans to extract water from.  To support the brick factory, a railroad would be constructed along the creek between Palmerton and Kunkletown.  Another part of the plan was to create a resort on the Blue Ridge near the Monroe/Carbon county line.
Kunkletown Station at terminus of Chestnut Ridge Railway
Property today owned by Gower Estates, LLC

The last part of the plan might be considered "visionary" from the viewpoint of 1970, considering the development that was about to commence.  But alas, the resort never came to fruition, and that the tourist trade has passed Kunkletown by may be a good thing.  However, a 35-room lodge with luxury appointments overlooking the brick factory was constructed along Chestnut Ridge Drive to host corporation executives when they were in town - first things first.

Chestnut Ridge Lodge, Chestnut Ridge Dr Kunkletown
Property owned today by Gower Estates, LLC

The Chestnut Ridge Railroad was built within two years, and the New York and Philadelphia Brick Tile and Terra Cotta Company opened in 1900.  In only two or three years, the brick company failed, and the railroad sold and renamed Chestnut Ridge Railway.  The brick company was replaced by the Chestnut Ridge White Brick Company, and this company also went bankrupt within a few years.  The railroad was sold in 1907 to The New Jersey Zinc Company.  By 1929, the brick company was defunct.  To this day, the Chestnut Ridge Railway name survives.

Twin 90' tall kiln stacks of brick factory at center; Chestnut Ridge Lodge top right
Site of factory and lodge owned today by Gower Estates, LLC

A side benefit was that Kunkletown residents could use the railroad to commute to the zinc company and other jobs in and near Palmerton, which they did until passenger service ceased in 1935.  The Kunkletown railway station became a hub for the bulk shipment of products to and from the area, with freight service continuing into the 1960's.

Chestnut Ridge Railway
Today mostly converted to a recreational rail trail

Passenger service fit for commoners - C.R.R. Railbus #51 ca. about 1930
Restored by and in possession of the Phillipsburg RR Historians

C.R.R. Railbus #51, converted to a maintenance vehicle ca. about 1960

The site of the Chestnut Ridge Lodge now has an unfoliated patch where the foundation once was.  Most of the railroad has been torn up today - leaving a 35' wide ribbon as a right of way for a recreational rail trail.  It leads one to consider the future and ponder, could there be any potential fringe benefits for the residents of Kunkletown of Nestle's development of the same site 5 or 15 years down the road, after the $750,000 payoff has been expended?  Continuous diesel exhaust, road degradation, truck noise, slowed traffic stuck behind 40-ton trucks going 10mph up hills, reduced property values.  Not a single job, no benefit to the tax base.  These are the only  "benefits".

Click the image to see the location of the Chestnut Ridge Corporation's improvements
and Nestle's planned operation on the Gower Estates LLC lot

Here is an article from a publication titled "Poconos Today", which recounts from Kunkletown resident Levi Smith's perspective the manner in which Kunkletown and its residents responded to and were affected by development associated with the Chestnut Ridge Corporation that commenced in 1898.



Monday, March 7, 2016

Landowner's attorney conspires with Eldred Planning Commission secretary and mother of landowner's bff to alter meeting minutes

You just could not make this up.  On the day following landowner Gower attorney James Wimmer's unannounced visit to the March 20, 2014 Eldred Township Planning Commission meeting, Mr. Wimmer via email directed planning commission secretary Darcy Gannon to alter her draft minutes.

Evidently Ms. Gannon sent her draft minutes to Mr. Wimmer for his "review" in the paneled offices back at Philip & Wimmer.  Instead of clearing up any misunderstandings in person with the planners and/or solicitor... you know... the evening before at the meeting itself.  Since when are draft meeting minutes sent to people outside the town for review?

Below, an excerpt of the official March 20, 2014 minutes adopted in April is shown on the right, and an excerpt of Mr. Wimmer's helpful email to "fill in the blanks" is shown on the left.
Note the following:
  • The official minutes are identical to the "modified" version that Mr. Wimmer crafted on behalf of his client, Ricky Gower - Ms. Gannon was most receptive to Mr. Wimmer's powers of suggestion.
  • Mr.Wimmer signed his email "Jimmy" - Mr. Wimmer has known Ms. Gannon for years.
  • Mr. Wimmer suggests that he and Ms. Gannon get together for a "date" to celebrate their work together.
  • Ricky Gower's significant other, Gretchen Gannon-Pettit, is an Eldred supervisor and more importantly the daughter of secretary Gannon.
  • Update 4/6 Note the email address - this message was passed through Gretchen Gannon-Pettit's township email account.
  • Mr. Wimmer has made a few most strategic changes - he warms up with the false and misleading statement that the use "would then no longer be permitted on Gower's property," (it never was) and tops things off with the critical (and misleading) phrase "the planners concurred with this request."
  • The misrepresentation that this use only consists of "piping and storage tanks."   No mention of 40-ton trucks roaring up the hills of Kunkletown every 10 minutes all day and until 11pm, which is the aspect that makes it an industrial use.
Mr. Wimmer must have been downright giddy when he learned that Ms. Gannon was able to comply with all his requests, out of the sight and earshot of the planning commission members and their solicitor - the people Ms. Gannon should have consulted if she had a question about what happened at the meeting.

No wonder Ms. Gannon is no longer employed at Eldred Twp.  Hopefully "Jimmy" bought her surf and turf.

Jimmy has the moves to get the job done


Objectors to Nestle's planned operation have cars vandalized - again

This past weekend, it is reported that at least two cars of residents who have petitioned to nullify the corrupt ordinance change that permitted Nestle to file its application, were vandalized.  This is second time these citizens have been targeted.  There have also been other cars vandalized, and an improvised explosive device that was launched over another objector's property, causing the destruction of tree limbs over an area at least a 60' x 30'.

The problem for the adult-aged juvenile delinquents perpetrating these senseless acts of violence is that they are fighting a losing battle against a small army.  The appeal in the Monroe Court of Common Pleas is a solid case.  The township has already admitted this, leaving Ricky Gower and his law firm (which is the same one that Eldred Twp taxpayers pay for to represent regional planning body CJERP) to attempt to intervene and defend rights Gower believes he is entitled to.  The only problem is, the ordinance change in question was the result of a corrupt process, with Elded Twp, CJERP, and the county planning commission bearing responsibility.  Furthermore, there are multiple issues with Nestle's current application, and the Eldred Twp Supervisors are in the process of overturning the amendment that was illegally passed.  Thus, the rights Mr. Gower believes he has are as good as a concrete foundation built on quick sand.

Whoever is vandalizing property is desperate, and realizes that their carefully-crafted diabolical plan to place an industrial operation in a commercial zoning district is about to go up in smoke.  And they have over 120 people to act out against.  Better get some more cans of paint...

An analysis of a recent court filing will be posted in the next few days, revealing just how weak the landowner's argument is that the ordinance was legally passed.  Incredibly (or not?), CJERP is maintaining the same position as the landowner, according to its Solicitor, whose law firm also represents the landowner.  CJERP may want to spend 5 minutes looking into the matter, admit the obvious, and stand alongside CJERP member Eldred Twp.  At CJERP's February meeting, its Solicitor announced his opinion that the ordinance was legally passed, but CJERP didn't debate or vote on this.  The Solicitor recommended CJERP not discuss the 2014 amendment.  Eldred Twp's representatives should make a motion at the next CJERP meeting that CJERP determine its position.  Conduct a frigging executive session if you must, then get a towel to wipe the cartons of eggs off your faces.  The sooner the better.

When Sharon Solt heard that candy was tossed back at people who were opposed to Nestle handing it out in a Halloween Parade in 2015, she said on Facebook "if that happened, it is wrong."  What does she have to say now that residents of Eldred Twp are having their cars vandalized, and an explosive launched at someone's property?  People who are doing nothing more than protecting their health, safety and welfare?  After all, she and Gretchen Gannon Pettit are the ones responsible for not overturning the amendment in Spring 2015, when it was discovered and recommended by the planning commission to be overturned, before Nestle went ahead and commenced expensive testing.  Supervisor Solt, what do you have to say to your residents?  This happened on your watch and is a result of your actions, and subsequent inaction.

Saturday, February 27, 2016

Landowner Gower's law firm advises gag order on CJERP members, and states that Gower and CJERP both believe the 2014 amendment was passed properly

James Fareri of the law firm of Newman, Williams, Mishkin, Corveleyn, Wolfe & Fareri is the CJERP Regional Planning Committee solicitor, and also was at the time that the 2014 water extraction amendment was passed.  Mr. Fareri's partner Marc Wolfe represents landowner Ricky Gower.

At the CJERP monthly meeting on February 25, 2016 Mr. Fareri made an announcement that due to a pending legal matter, he has advised CJERP members to not discuss the events surrounding CJERP's involvement in passage of the amendment.  This advice comes more than a month after Mr. Wolfe entered his appearance for Ricky Gower in the court action.


CJERP member and Eldred Township resident Bob Boileau asked if this represents a conflict of interest.  Mr Fareri's response was fascinating - he stated that since CJERP and landowner Gower both maintain that the 2014 amendment was passed properly, there is no conflict of interest.

Don Moore then rose to speak at courtesy of the floor, and pointed out that Eldred Township has admitted through its solicitor that mistakes were made, so Eldred Township's position is adverse to landowner Gower.  Mr. Fareri stated again that CJERP and Mr. Gower are "on the same side of the issue" and that both "believe the amendment was passed properly."

Mr. Moore requested that if he was unable to have a discussion with CJERP members, that he be permitted to read a statement into the record.  He proceeded to read a list of more than ten errors that were made in passage of the amendment, by CJER Planning Consultant Carson Helfrich, CJER Solicitor Fareri, CJER, and the Monroe County Planning Commission.  However, CJERP Chairman Gould did not waver from the advice of Mr. Fareri, and there was no response from a CJERP member.  Mr. Gould was the Chairman of CJER in 2014 when CJER totally failed in its responsibility to vet this amendment.


It is hard to believe that someone other than the Eldred Township CJERP representatives didn't realize that Mr. Fareri's assertion that the amendment was passed properly was just shredded.
Update 3/17 -  An itemized list of errors correlated to a pictorial representation of how an amendment should be passed is shown here.  Note that errors were made at every single step of the process.  Solicitor Fareri's position that the amendment was passed properly on behalf of CJERP is absurd, but his law firm has a duty to hold this position on behalf of its other client - the land owner.

Mr. Gould seemed very pleased to not have to discuss responsibility, didn't thank Mr. Moore, and shouted "NEXT SPEAKER".  Mr. Moore expected gruff and rude treatment, because others have been treated similarly by the leadership at CJERP meetings.  However, the wax museum, deaf and dumb treatment was not expected. There was no mention by CJERP of the questions about the amendment that Mr. Moore submitted to CJERP per CJERP Planner Matt Neeb's request on December 17 and December 31, 2015, to which CJERP has never responded.  Another Eldred Township resident submitted written questions to CJERP in November 2015, and they haven't been answered either.  Perhaps Chairman Gould, CJER and "professionals" have some culpability in this matter:

Chairman Gould states at the March 2014 CJER meeting that consistent definitions and land use and consistency with the Comprehensive Plan were goals of CJER.  One month later at CJER's May meeting the water extraction amendment was adopted that violated these consistency and land use goals of the Comprehensive Plan.  Chairman Gould asked Eldred residents at CJER's September 2015 meeting "why are you here?" and told them to "go back to Eldred Township and ask what happened in 2014 there." Today he has adopted the position that no member of CJERP shall discuss what happened in 2014.  Mr. Gould, doesn't this go far beyond a local matter?

Here are a few obvious questions:
  • How did Solicitor Fareri formulate his opinion that CJERP is on the same side of the issue as landowner Gower?  CJERP has not discussed this in a meeting, heard a motion or held a vote.   Is this being handled the same way as matters in 2014, where unathorized executive decisions were made by multiple parties without public discussion, deliberation, and then a vote? 
  • What is CJERP's position on whether it agrees with landowner Gower, or with Eldred Township?  It is CJERP that determines its position, not its Solicitor.
  • If Mr. Fareri is correct that CJERP did everything appropriately, why is was a gag order requested by him?
  • Mr. Fareri advised the gag order on CJERP after his partner commenced representation of landowner Gower on January 4, 2016.  Is his gag order based on protecting CJERP members and consultants, someone else, a combination of the two?
  • Why wouldn't CJERP agree to take the position of CJERP member township Eldred, in the face of the overwhelming evidence the procedure used violated the statutory procedure?
  • What liability would CJERP members or consultants be exposed to if they simply told the truth about what happened in 2014?  Failing to properly advertise or ensure an amendment was authorized are not criminal offenses, and wouldn't result in a fine.
  • Wouldn't a better justification to not talk about what public officials and consultants did in 2014 be that it is believed someone was corrupt, not that everything was done properly?
  • What function does the CJERP Planning Committee actually perform, other than add a layer of volunteers and consultants who have no land use planning background between the Monroe County Planning Commission and local planners in Eldred Township?  Is more better?


Feb 26 letter to CJERP, recommending that CJERP appoint a new law firm and planning consultant, and adopt a position aligned with member township Eldred that the water extraction amendment not passed per statute

Following this meeting, Mr.Moore sent a letter to CJERP memorializing the events of the meeting, and made three recommendations:
  • Appoint a new law firm to perform the duties of Solicitor, and terminate the contract with Solicitor Fareri's law firm
  • Adopt Eldred Township's position that the 2014 amendment was passed improperly
  • Appoint a new Planning Consultant, and terminate the contract with Carson Helfrich

Thursday, February 25, 2016

Explosion Adjacent to Eldred Twp Nestle Water Extraction Site - IED or "Atmospheric Event"?

On Sunday morning, a very loud explosion rocked houses adjacent to the site of the Nestle/Deer Park water extraction operation.  Reports are that it ripped a "thirty foot wide path" through trees, on a property across Chestnut Ridge Road from the site.  The explosion apparently occurred at an elevated level above ground, ripping apart the crowns of trees, and raining tree branches down to the ground.  Walls of houses shook, and it was reported there was some broken glass on a resident's property.

Tree debris - if it walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck -
it's a duck

It is rumored that one agency that received a report of this event has suggested that the cause is an "atmospheric event".

I found this interesting.  What is an "atmospheric event"?  If someone breaks wind, is that an atmospheric event?  It's man-made global warming, for sure, but I don't believe it is an atmospheric event.  An atmospheric event is an electrical storm, for example.

Come on.  Google it.  I guarantee that you won't find improvised explosive devices included in atmospheric events - trust me.  People who have seen the damage suggest C4 or a stick of dynamite.  I'm not sure how you convert one of those into a surface to air missile, but that sounds a lot more likely than an atmospheric event.  When God starts dropping bombs from the sky, we're in a heap more trouble than tractor trailer traffic all day and night.



Wednesday, February 24, 2016

Nestle Attempts to Disqualify Zoning Hearing Board Chairman at First Special Exception Permit Hearing

The number of Solictiors in the Eldred Township Fire Hall outnumbered the entire membership of the Zoning Hearing Board, including its the two alternates.  The hearing lasted 3-1/2 hours, with little accomplished other than watching lightning lick around the edges of the fire hall, qualification of the standing of several residents, a desperate effort by Nestle to disqualify Zoning Hearing Board Chairman O'Donnell, qualifying Nestle's engineer to testify, and setting the next two meeting dates.

Several Attorneys, Representing Several Entitites
The legal representation included two attorneys on behalf of Eldred Township, Jordan Yeager and an associate, Monroe County Asst DA Chad Martinez representing the Zoning Hearing Board, Jim Preston representing Objectors, Tim Weston representing Nestle, and Marc Wolfe representing landowner Ricky Gower.  Update 2/27 - It is believed that another attorney at Mr. Wolfe's law firm, Robert Kidwell, was also present to represent landowner Gower.

It remains an unanswered question how the law firm of Newman, Williams, Mishkin, Corveleyn, Wolfe & Fareri can represent both Gower and Eldred Township (Fareri is the CJERP Solicitor, partly contracted by Eldred Township), given that in the pending court appeal these two are adverse parties.  Hey, its Monroe County - anything goes.

Update 2/27 - At CJERP's monthly meeting the following evening (2/25),  Mr. Wolfe's partner and CJERP Solicitor Fareri announced that he has advised CJERP to not discuss any of the facts surrounding the 2014 amendment review and adoption process.  He was questioned by Eldred Township CJERP representative Bob Boileau whether he has a conflict of interest since his partner represents the landowner, and Mr. Fareri's reply was "since CJERP and landowner Gower are both of the belief that the 2014 amendment was properly adopted, they are on the same side of the issue, and there is no conflict of interest."  A recommendation was sent to CJERP on February 26 to replace Solicitor Fareri's law firm.


Sharon Solt was not observed at tonight's hearing, to see more of the fallout of her actions in 2014, when as Township Secretary she forwarded the unauthorized water extraction amendment to the Monroe County Planning Commission and the Eldred Township Planning Commission that had not been authorized by the supervisors.  Personally, I'd be too embarrassed to attend if I were she, but having seen this person in action this is highly unlikely the explanation.  Nor do I believe the double-barreled single finger salute of the last meeting was related - I think that slid off her back like a crushed tomato off an oil-coated sloth.

Unwavering Dedication of Residents
The room was full of dedicated Eldred Township residents - dedicated to seeing that Nestle leaves town as soon as possible, from this reporter's view.   It is both heartwarming and heart wrenching to see these citizens turn out meeting after meeting, sitting attentively and looking for the first sign that this nightmare may come to an end.  There are obvious strong bonds withing the community, and these residents are unified in their opposition to this project.  The tension in this room, which has become a regular meeting place due to the community backlash, is often palpable, broken by occasional smiles and knowing looks exchanged between people across various spans of the room.  In this gathering place, where a visitor imagines a wide variety of community activities are held, for the foreseeable future these solemn gatherings will be repeated at least twice more.  The next two Zoning Hearing Board meetings are scheduled for March 30 and April 20.

Attempt to Disqualify Chairman O'Donnell 
for Using Commonly Used Descriptor of Nestle/Deer Park
It was not a surprise when Nestle Solicitor Weston launched into an attack on Mr. O'Donnell, because within the community it has been discussed that a bitter and manipulative passed-over candidate for the Zoning Hearing Board tried to use words in a letter Mr. O'Donnell had written to a environmental organization to argue that he should be disqualified from the Nestle hearing.  Perhaps she dreams they will haul her down to the Fire Hall and appoint her to hear this case - or perhaps she is just vindictive - or perhaps she's trying to do a solid for someone.  It boils down to O'Donnell referring in September 2015 to a possible Nestle operation in Eldred Twp to being a potential nuisance.  Sounds like common sense, but Mr. Weston made it sound like Mr. O'Donnell would not have an open mind.  He grilled Mr. O'Donnell so much that a guy nearby said "that attorney is going to rip the old guy to shreds."  Mr. O'Donnell's explanation for the source of the term "nuisance" was simply that he saw that description of Nestle in the newspaper. Reality bites, eh?  Mr. O'Donnell held up well, and then Mr. Weston made the mistake of an exaggeration that everyone in the room caught - after droning on and on about case law and ethics and the appearance of impropriety, in an authoritative tone he then stated that Mr. O'Donnell made this comment while Nestle had a pending application - which totally misstated the facts.  Nestle filed its application on December 30th. This misrepresentation was identified immediately by Mr. Yeager.  Mr. O'Donnell stated quite succinctly that he has not yet seen any evidence, has an open mind, and will make a decision once all the testimony is complete.

Mr. Weston's motion to have Mr. O'Donnell's disqualified will be briefed by attorneys prior to the next hearing, and Mr. Martinez will issue a ruling prior to commencement of testimony.  If you ask me, this is little more than the result of a bitter passed-over woman trying to influence the makeup of a Board.  I've been rejected from serving on my town's Zoning Hearing Board, and felt I was more qualified than the person chosen.  It's not that hard to move on with life - not so hard that you have to go sand bagging people.

More dirty tricks by government, or "oversight"?
Residents who believe they have standing were requested to fill out a form in advance, with their justification.  A resident who owns property along the target site's property line - whose standing is thus unquestionable, reports that she submitted her form yesterday at the township building, to supervisor and disgraced former Secretary Sharon Solt.  The form was not in the pile when she arrived at the hearing.  Naturally, this presented no problem, since the form was merely to accelerate the vetting process during the hearing.  This resident was qualified immediately when she presented herself at the hearing.  Salute!

The next meeting should be more productive, with this one spent mostly on housekeeping.

Monday, February 22, 2016

CJERP Regional Planning Committee to Consider Eldred Twp Water Extraction Amendment at its February 25th Meeting

Eldred Township residents should be aware that the water extraction amendment that will overturn the one passed in 2014 will be reviewed by the CJERP Regional Planning Committee at its Thursday, February 25, 2016 meeting at 7pm at the Chestnuthill Municipal Building, 271 Rt 715.  This won't affect Nestle's pending application, but will pertain to future applications.  The Eldred BOS will hold a meeting in March to review recommendations and take action on this amendment.

Review of Stunning List of Errors CJER and its Solicitor Made in 2014
CJER (its name in 2014) is the body which held the meeting on March 27, 2014 at which Planning Consultant Carson Helfrich stated he had the water extraction amendment in hand, and would move forward with it if authorized.  (1) Mr.Helfrich was not authorized by the Eldred supervisors, but moved forward with it anyway.  Strike one.

CJER had the following responsibilities, according to the CJER Intergovernmental Agreement:
  • (2) review amendments from the member townships
  • (3) review recommendations on member township amendments from the Monroe County Planning Commission
  • (4) review recommendations from the remaining CJER townships when one township submits an amendment
Furthermore, in the March through May 2014 period, (5) CJER Solicitor James Fareri was solely responsible for reviewing amendments, and (6) CJER had the responsibility to advertise amendments.

CJER cancelled its April 2014 meeting in its infinite wisdom, and there is no evidence any of the reviews of the amendment that it was charged with were done.  Strikes two through four.  

CJER met on May 1, and at this meeting after no discussion, the Eldred Supervisors voted to approve the amendment.  Mr. Fareri apparently did not catch the very clear land use change from industrial to light manufacturing of water extraction, or the fact that this change would make water extraction in Eldred different than the uniform definition in the other CJER townships.  Strike five.

The advertisement for Eldred Township water extraction amendment for the May 1 meeting, which was authorized by CJER and CJER Solicitor Fareri, was not authorized by Eldred Township.  Strike six.

All of the above happened on CJER's watch, yet to date they have taken zero responsibility.

Will CJREP and the Monroe County Planning Commission Play Ball, 
or Try to Cover their Asses by Recommending Against the Amendment?
It is suggested that Eldred Township residents may wish to attend Thursday evening's meeting, and see if CJERP (its current name) can do any better than it did in 2014.  The same key players are involved, from leadership to planner Matt Neeb to the solicitor.

Let's hope to see a discussion about how the new amendment actually is compatible with the goals of the Comprehensive Plan, while the one that that CJER failed to review (thus effectively approving it) totally violated the Plan.  Or will CJER and the Monroe County Planning Commission refuse to admit the stunning errors made across the board in 2014, and try to cover their asses by stubbornly questioning Eldred's new amendment?

My Wish
I dearly hope that CJERP recommends against approval of the amendment.  Why?  Because it will reflect on CJERP and its solicitor (whose law firm is representing the interests of the owner of the land Nestle is leasing - no conflict of interest there), not Eldred Township's amendment.  Because of the primary goal of consistency, the only possible defense is that the other four townships agree and wish to change water extraction to a light manufacturing use.  Then the Monroe County Planning Commission will have to argue that water extraction is of light manufacturing intensity.  But it isn't - not with constant truck traffic of 40 ton+ vehicles.  That argument can't be won.  

If this happens, Eldred Supervisors will ignore this advice (remember these agencies are advisory) and pass the amendment, to undo the egregious errors made by the Monroe County Planning Commission, CJER, the CJER Solicitor, the Regional Planning Consultant, Eldred Township Supervisors, the Eldred Township Planning Commission Solicitor, and Eldred Township's Secretary Solt in 2014.  You just can not make this shit up.


Turn north on Rt 715 at the Wawa